Cardiovascular

Anesthesia Clinical Practice Guidelines for Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome: A Modified Delphi Survey.

TL;DR

A three-round modified Delphi survey with 15 experts achieved consensus on seven anesthesia clinical practice guidelines for patients with Ehlers-Danlos syndrome, establishing 'the first consensus-based clinical practice guidelines for the anesthetic care of patients with EDS.'

Key Findings

Consensus was achieved for all seven preliminary anesthesia guidelines for EDS by the third round of a modified Delphi survey.

  • A three-round modified Delphi survey methodology was used.
  • 15 experts in anesthesia and EDS participated.
  • Seven preliminary guidelines were developed from a comprehensive literature review prior to the Delphi rounds.
  • Guidelines were evaluated and refined across all three rounds before consensus was reached.

Comprehensive airway assessment was recommended for all EDS subtypes as a key anesthesia guideline.

  • The recommendation applies across all subtypes of EDS, not limited to specific variants.
  • EDS is characterized by joint hyperextensibility, skin hyperelasticity, and increased tissue friability, all of which may affect airway management.
  • This guideline was among the seven that achieved expert consensus by the third Delphi round.

Bleeding risk evaluation and consideration of desmopressin was recommended for classical, classical-like, kyphoscoliotic, and vascular EDS subtypes.

  • The recommendation for desmopressin consideration was specific to four named EDS subtypes: classical, classical-like, kyphoscoliotic, and vascular EDS.
  • This guideline reflects the increased tissue friability and bleeding risk associated with these subtypes.
  • Consensus on this guideline was achieved by the third Delphi round.

Multimodal analgesia and regional anesthesia strategies were recommended specifically for hypermobile EDS.

  • The guideline targets hypermobile EDS (hEDS), which is described as the most common subtype.
  • Multimodal analgesia approaches were recommended, reflecting the complex pain profiles associated with hEDS.
  • Regional anesthesia strategies were included as part of the pain management recommendations for this subtype.

Perioperative planning that incorporates common EDS comorbidities was established as a consensus guideline.

  • The guideline recognizes that EDS patients frequently present with significant comorbidities relevant to perioperative care.
  • No specific comorbidities were enumerated in the abstract, but the guideline requires their systematic incorporation into planning.
  • Consensus was achieved for this guideline by the third Delphi round.

Cautious use of regional or neuraxial anesthesia in vascular EDS was recommended, requiring individual risk-benefit analysis due to hematoma risk.

  • Vascular EDS was specifically identified as requiring heightened caution with regional and neuraxial anesthesia techniques.
  • The primary concern cited is hematoma risk associated with these anesthesia approaches in vascular EDS patients.
  • The guideline calls for individualized risk-benefit analysis rather than a blanket contraindication.
  • Consensus was achieved for this guideline by the third Delphi round.

The study acknowledges limitations of small sample size and gaps in existing evidence base underlying the guidelines.

  • The expert panel consisted of 15 participants, which the authors identify as a sample size limitation.
  • The authors note 'gaps in existing evidence' as a constraint on the strength of the recommendations.
  • Despite these limitations, the authors characterize the guidelines as providing 'a framework to enhance patient safety by guiding clinical decision-making and encouraging future research in the perioperative management of EDS.'

What This Means

Ehlers-Danlos syndrome (EDS) is a group of inherited disorders affecting connective tissue, causing symptoms like unusually flexible joints, stretchy skin, and fragile tissues. People with EDS face higher risks during surgery and anesthesia, but until now there were no standardized guidelines to help anesthesia providers care for these patients safely. This research used a structured expert consensus method called a Delphi survey, bringing together 15 specialists in both anesthesia and EDS over three rounds of evaluation to develop and refine recommendations. The study produced seven consensus-based guidelines covering key areas of perioperative care. These include performing thorough airway assessments for all EDS patients before anesthesia, evaluating bleeding risk and potentially using a medication called desmopressin for certain subtypes, using multimodal pain management approaches for the most common subtype (hypermobile EDS), planning for associated health conditions that often accompany EDS, and exercising special caution with spinal or regional nerve blocks in vascular EDS due to the risk of dangerous blood clots forming near the spinal cord. This research suggests that structured expert consensus can fill important gaps when clinical trial data is limited or absent, as is the case with rare conditions like EDS. The authors acknowledge that the panel was small and that the underlying published evidence has gaps, but describe these guidelines as the first of their kind for EDS anesthesia care. The findings provide a practical starting point for anesthesia providers treating EDS patients and may help reduce perioperative complications in this vulnerable population while also pointing toward areas where future research is needed.

Have a question about this study?

Citation

Amaral D, Patrick K, Redeker G, Horvath C, Morgan B, Dalley C. (2026). Anesthesia Clinical Practice Guidelines for Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome: A Modified Delphi Survey.. AANA journal. https://doi.org/10.70278/AANAJ/.0000001099