Comparative effectiveness of progressive moderate- to high-intensity peripheral and inspiratory muscle training combined with aerobic exercise in community-dwelling older adults: A randomized clinical trial.
Moderate- to high-intensity peripheral and inspiratory muscle training, when combined with aerobic training, significantly enhances respiratory muscle strength, functional capacity, and quality of life in community-dwelling older adults.
Key Findings
Results
Between-group comparison revealed a significant difference only in the WHOQOL-OLD death and dying subscale, with greater improvement in the IMT group.
P = .019, d = 0.185 for the between-group difference in the death and dying subscale
34 community-dwelling older adults were randomized: PMT group (n = 17) and IMT group (n = 17)
All other outcome measures did not show significant between-group differences
Assessments were conducted at baseline and after 10 weeks of training
Results
Peripheral muscle training combined with aerobic exercise produced significant within-group improvements in expiratory muscle strength and functional capacity.
MEP improved significantly: P = .003, d = 0.876
MEP% improved significantly: P = .002, d = 0.932
6-minute walk test (6-MWT) improved significantly: P = .001, d = 0.974
WHOQOL-OLD sensory abilities subscale also improved significantly: P = .035, d = 0.528
PMT was performed at 60 to 80% of one-repetition maximum (1RM), targeting upper and lower extremities
Results
Inspiratory muscle training combined with aerobic exercise produced significant within-group improvements in inspiratory muscle strength, functional capacity, and quality of life related to death and dying.
MIP improved significantly: P = .002, d = 0.788
MIP% improved significantly: P = .001, d = 1.032
6-MWT improved significantly: P = .003, d = 0.889
WHOQOL-OLD death and dying subscale improved significantly: P = .040, d = 0.564
IMT was performed at 60 to 80% of baseline maximum inspiratory pressure using a threshold IMT device
Methods
Both groups participated in supervised step-aerobic sessions as a common intervention component across the 10-week program.
Step-aerobic sessions were conducted twice weekly for 10 weeks
Target intensity was 50 to 70% of individual maximum heart rate
Outcome measures included hand grip strength, MIP, MEP, 6-MWT, SPPB, SARC-F questionnaire, and WHOQOL-OLD
Participants were community-dwelling older adults
Results
Peripheral muscle training combined with aerobic exercise improved expiratory muscle strength despite not targeting respiratory muscles directly.
MEP and MEP% showed significant improvements in the PMT group (P = .003 and P = .002, respectively)
Effect sizes for MEP (d = 0.876) and MEP% (d = 0.932) were large
The PMT group did not perform dedicated respiratory muscle training
This finding suggests peripheral resistance training may have secondary effects on expiratory muscle strength
Results
Both groups demonstrated significant improvements in functional capacity as measured by the 6-minute walk test.
PMT group 6-MWT improvement: P = .001, d = 0.974
IMT group 6-MWT improvement: P = .003, d = 0.889
Both effect sizes were large (approaching d = 1.0)
No significant between-group difference in 6-MWT was reported, suggesting comparable functional capacity gains
What This Means
This research suggests that two different types of muscle training programs, when combined with aerobic exercise, can meaningfully improve physical and respiratory fitness in older adults living in the community. One program focused on strengthening the arms and legs using resistance exercises (peripheral muscle training, or PMT), while the other focused on strengthening the breathing muscles using a special breathing resistance device (inspiratory muscle training, or IMT). Both programs lasted 10 weeks and included twice-weekly step aerobics sessions. The key finding was that both groups improved their ability to walk longer distances and showed gains in relevant muscle strength, but each program tended to produce its most pronounced improvements in its targeted area — the PMT group improved expiratory (breathing out) muscle strength, while the IMT group improved inspiratory (breathing in) muscle strength.
The only meaningful difference between the two groups was in a quality-of-life measure related to attitudes toward death and dying, where the IMT group showed greater improvement. This is a specific subscale of a quality-of-life questionnaire designed for older adults, and it reflects how at ease participants felt with thoughts about death — an aspect of psychological well-being that may be influenced by improved breathing capacity and physical confidence. Both groups also showed improvements in quality-of-life measures related to their specific training focus.
This research suggests that both peripheral resistance training and inspiratory muscle training, when combined with aerobic exercise, are viable options for improving the physical fitness and quality of life of older adults. The choice between them may depend on an individual's specific needs — for example, those with breathing difficulties might particularly benefit from IMT, while those needing general strength gains might benefit more from PMT. The study was relatively small (34 participants total), so larger studies would be needed to confirm and extend these findings.
Check Your Own Numbers
Upload your bloodwork. We'll cross-reference your results against this study and 4,700 others.
Uyanik S, Akinci B. (2026). Comparative effectiveness of progressive moderate- to high-intensity peripheral and inspiratory muscle training combined with aerobic exercise in community-dwelling older adults: A randomized clinical trial.. Medicine. https://doi.org/10.1097/MD.0000000000049057