Cardiovascular

Cost-effectiveness of percutaneous patent foramen ovale closure versus medical therapy for cryptogenic stroke prevention: A Chinese healthcare perspective.

TL;DR

PFO closure demonstrated economic dominance over medical therapy in Chinese cryptogenic stroke patients, yielding 1.41 additional QALYs while reducing lifetime costs by $4,045 per patient, resulting in a negative ICER of -$2,868 per QALY.

Key Findings

PFO closure was economically dominant over medical therapy, providing more QALYs at lower cost.

  • PFO closure yielded 13.42 QALYs compared to 12.01 QALYs for medical therapy, a difference of 1.41 additional QALYs.
  • Lifetime costs were lower with PFO closure ($8,847) than with medical therapy ($12,892), a reduction of $4,045 per patient.
  • The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) was -$2,868 per QALY, indicating superior outcomes at lower cost.
  • Results were evaluated against China's willingness-to-pay threshold of $37,654 per QALY.

Probabilistic sensitivity analysis showed a high probability of cost-effectiveness for PFO closure at the Chinese willingness-to-pay threshold.

  • Probabilistic sensitivity analysis revealed a 94.2% probability of cost-effectiveness at the Chinese threshold of $37,654 per QALY.
  • This analysis was conducted to examine parameter uncertainty and model robustness.

One-way sensitivity analyses consistently produced negative ICERs across all parameter ranges, supporting the robustness of the dominance finding.

  • One-way sensitivity analyses showed negative ICERs across all parameter ranges tested.
  • Time horizon and psychological comorbidity costs exerted the greatest influence on results among the parameters examined.

A Markov cohort model with a 30-year time horizon and Chinese-specific data was used to conduct the cost-effectiveness analysis.

  • The model included four health states: stable, post-minor recurrent stroke, post-moderate-to-severe recurrent stroke, and death.
  • Model cycles were 3 months in length over a 30-year time horizon.
  • The analysis adopted a Chinese healthcare payer perspective.
  • Transition probabilities were derived primarily from the RESPECT trial extended follow-up data.
  • Cost data were obtained from multi-center hospital surveys to reflect Chinese-specific costs.

Patent foramen ovale occurs in approximately 25% of cryptogenic stroke patients, with paradoxical embolization as a key pathophysiological mechanism.

  • The prevalence of PFO in cryptogenic stroke patients is reported as approximately 25%.
  • Paradoxical embolization is identified as a key pathophysiological mechanism linking PFO to cryptogenic stroke.
  • Recent trials have established the clinical efficacy of percutaneous PFO closure in reducing recurrent stroke risk.

Have a question about this study?

Citation

Chen C, Xu T, Zeng Z, Miao J, Hu R, Gao Y, et al.. (2026). Cost-effectiveness of percutaneous patent foramen ovale closure versus medical therapy for cryptogenic stroke prevention: A Chinese healthcare perspective.. PloS one. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0345015