Cardiovascular

CTA-based planning for clipping of paraclinoid aneurysms: TS-ACP validation and selective contralateral interoptic outcomes.

TL;DR

TS-ACP classification provided a high-sensitivity CTA-based estimate of the operative intradural category, and prespecified geometry was strongly associated with contralateral corridor selection, with no excess permanent visual morbidity observed in carefully selected contralateral cases.

Key Findings

CTA-based TS-ACP classification matched operative distal dural ring (DDR) assessment in 90.5% of paraclinoid aneurysms with substantial inter-rater agreement.

  • Classification matched in 95 of 105 aneurysms (90.5%)
  • Kappa statistic κ = 0.76, indicating substantial agreement
  • Two blinded reviewers retrospectively applied the classification to preoperative CTA
  • DSA provided complementary anatomical characterization
  • Registry cohort included 105 adults treated during 2011–2024

TS-ACP classification demonstrated 100% sensitivity and 100% negative predictive value for identifying the operative intradural category.

  • Sensitivity for identifying the operative intradural category was 100%
  • Specificity was 70.0%
  • Negative predictive value was 100%
  • These metrics suggest the classification reliably rules out the intradural category when negative
  • Positive predictive value was not explicitly reported in the abstract

Favorable interoptic geometry was significantly more frequent among patients selected for contralateral interoptic clipping compared to ipsilateral clipping.

  • Favorable geometry present in 76.7% of contralateral cases vs. 32.0% of ipsilateral cases
  • p < 0.001; OR 6.98 (95% CI 2.63–18.52)
  • Association remained after excluding multiple-aneurysm operations: OR 13.93 (95% CI 2.88–67.37)
  • 75 patients underwent ipsilateral and 30 underwent contralateral interoptic clipping
  • Corridor selection was nonrandomized and anatomy-driven

Permanent visual worsening at 12 months occurred in 7 of 75 ipsilateral cases and 1 of 30 contralateral cases, with no statistically significant difference between groups.

  • 7/75 (9.3%) ipsilateral cases had permanent visual worsening vs. 1/30 (3.3%) contralateral cases
  • p = 0.43; difference was not statistically significant
  • The study was explicitly noted to be underpowered for comparative safety inference
  • Sparse events, anatomical differences, and nonrandomized selection preclude robust comparative safety conclusions
  • Principal clinical safety endpoint was permanent visual worsening at 12 months

CTA/DSA-confirmed complete aneurysm occlusion was achieved in 92.9% of patients.

  • Complete occlusion achieved in 79 of 85 patients (92.9%)
  • Occlusion was confirmed by both CTA and DSA
  • Data available for 85 of the 105 total patients in the cohort
  • The study did not report reasons for incomplete occlusion in the remaining cases in the abstract

What This Means

This research suggests that a CT angiography (CTA)-based measurement system called the TS-ACP classification can reliably predict the surgical characteristics of paraclinoid aneurysms — abnormal bulges in blood vessels near the base of the brain — before an operation begins. In a group of 105 patients treated over 13 years, the preoperative CT scan correctly identified the key surgical anatomy in over 90% of cases, and crucially, it never missed cases where the aneurysm was located in a surgically important intradural (inside the protective brain lining) position, meaning surgeons could use this tool with confidence to avoid underestimating surgical complexity. The study also examined a less common surgical approach called contralateral interoptic clipping, where the surgeon approaches the aneurysm from the opposite side, passing between the optic nerves. This approach was much more likely to be chosen when the patient's anatomy showed favorable geometry — a wide enough corridor between the optic nerves. Patients selected for the contralateral approach did not appear to have higher rates of permanent vision worsening compared to those who had the more conventional ipsilateral approach (1 in 30 vs. 7 in 75), though the study was too small to draw firm conclusions about safety differences. This research suggests that detailed preoperative CTA imaging, analyzed using the TS-ACP classification, can meaningfully guide surgical planning for these complex aneurysms. Surgeons may be able to use this information to select the safest surgical corridor before the operation, potentially improving outcomes. However, because patients were not randomly assigned to different surgical approaches and the number of adverse events was small, larger prospective studies would be needed to confirm whether one approach is truly safer than the other in appropriately selected patients.

Have a question about this study?

Citation

Seddighi A, Seddighi A, Hosseini S. (2026). CTA-based planning for clipping of paraclinoid aneurysms: TS-ACP validation and selective contralateral interoptic outcomes.. Clinical neurology and neurosurgery. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.clineuro.2026.109626