Cyber Dating and Sexual Fantasies in Men Who Have Sex with Men from Spain: Analyzing the Intersection of Technology, Intimate Relationships, and Violence on Scruff
A. Pablo & Antonio García-Gómez • Archives of Sexual Behavior • 2026
Analysis of 300 Scruff profiles from Spanish MSM aged 40-50 identified three recurring script clusters—feminized self-presentations, rape-themed fantasies, and dominant top identities—that collectively 'reiterate gendered power asymmetries' and authorize sexual aggression within MSM digital spaces.
Key Findings
Results
Feminized self-presentations on Scruff profiles commodified femininity and aligned passivity with desirability.
This pattern was identified as one of three recurring clusters across the 300 profiles analyzed.
These presentations staged femininity in ways that linked passive sexual roles to attractiveness and availability.
The authors describe this as a form of femmephobia that 'reworks heteronormative gender hierarchies within MSM spaces.'
Profiles drew on broader cultural scripts that associate femininity with sexual accessibility.
Results
Rape-themed sexual fantasies were present in profiles and framed male sexual entitlement as exciting and largely unproblematic.
This constituted the second of three recurring script clusters identified in the discourse analysis.
Such fantasies were described as normalizing sexual aggression by presenting it as desirable rather than harmful.
The authors note these scripts contribute to the 'downplaying of harm' associated with sexual violence.
The authors acknowledge that some profiles invite readings emphasizing 'consensual kink or playful exaggeration,' underscoring interpretive complexity.
Results
Dominant 'top' identities in profiles assumed control and initiative while constructing feminized partners as available and violable.
This was identified as the third recurring cluster of sexual scripts in the sample.
These profiles positioned the dominant partner as having inherent entitlement to sexual initiative and control.
Feminized partners were discursively constructed as 'available and violable' within these scripts.
This pattern was linked to the broader authorization of sexual aggression documented across the three clusters.
Methods
The study used a mixed methods discourse analysis of 300 Scruff profiles from men aged 40 to 50 residing in the Madrid region of Spain.
The sample was restricted to midlife users (ages 40–50), a group the authors note has been underexamined in prior research on MSM digital contexts.
The platform studied was Scruff, a geosocial networking application used by MSM.
The geographic scope was limited to the Madrid region of Spain.
The methodological approach was mixed methods discourse analysis.
The study was designed to address gaps in rape culture research, which has 'largely focused on heterosexual women and has underexamined men who have sex with men in digital contexts.'
Results
Enactments of masculinity and femininity on Scruff profiles were found to be closely tied to the authorization of sexual aggression and the downplaying of harm.
The three script clusters collectively demonstrated how gendered positioning operates to normalize sexual violence discursively.
Femmephobia was identified as a mechanism through which heteronormative gender hierarchies are reproduced within MSM spaces.
The patterns documented contribute to 'technology facilitated sexual violence' as a research area.
The authors note that MSM sexual scripts 'reiterate gendered power asymmetries' identified in broader rape culture literature.
Conclusions
The study concludes there is a need for consent-focused sexual health education tailored specifically to MSM.
This implication follows from the documentation of scripts normalizing sexual aggression and entitlement.
The authors situate this recommendation within 'debates on masculinities, platform-mediated intimacies, and technology-facilitated sexual violence.'
The finding extends rape culture scholarship beyond its traditional focus on heterosexual contexts.
The recommendation addresses both the digital platform context and the specific cultural scripts identified.
What This Means
This research suggests that sexual self-presentation profiles on the gay dating app Scruff, when examined among middle-aged men in the Madrid region of Spain, frequently follow recognizable patterns that mirror broader cultural scripts about gender and power. Researchers analyzed 300 profiles from men between 40 and 50 years old and found three common themes: profiles where men presented themselves in feminized, passive ways that linked that passivity to sexual desirability; profiles that described rape-themed fantasies in ways that treated male sexual entitlement as normal or exciting; and profiles from men identifying as dominant 'tops' that positioned their partners as inherently available and subject to their control. The researchers note that some of these profiles could also be interpreted as consensual kink or playful expression, acknowledging that online profiles are not straightforward to interpret.
This research suggests that the same kinds of gendered power dynamics and normalization of sexual aggression that scholars have documented in heterosexual contexts also appear in digital spaces used by men who have sex with men, though they take a distinctive form. Specifically, the study points to 'femmephobia'—stigma toward feminine expression—as a way that rigid gender hierarchies borrowed from heterosexual culture get reproduced within gay and bisexual men's communities online. The study fills a gap in existing research, which has rarely focused on MSM users of dating apps or on middle-aged users specifically.
This research suggests that sexual health education and platform policies addressing consent and sexual violence need to be designed with MSM communities in mind, not only heterosexual populations. The findings indicate that the digital environment of apps like Scruff can serve as a space where harmful sexual scripts are rehearsed and reinforced, pointing to a role for both education and platform design in addressing technology-facilitated sexual violence in these communities.
A. Pablo, Antonio García-Gómez. (2026). Cyber Dating and Sexual Fantasies in Men Who Have Sex with Men from Spain: Analyzing the Intersection of Technology, Intimate Relationships, and Violence on Scruff. Archives of Sexual Behavior. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10508-026-03417-1