Body Composition

Different body components associate differently with diet quality and physical activity in men and in women: a cross-sectional analysis.

TL;DR

In a cross-sectional analysis of 435 Swiss adults, different body composition measures (BMI, SMI, FMI, VAT) were associated differently with diet quality, specific food groups, and physical activity in men and women, in line with evolutionary hypotheses on sex-specific energy allocation.

Key Findings

Age showed the strongest positive association with fat mass index (FMI) and visceral fat (VAT) in both sexes.

  • Data came from 2021 of a cohort study of the Swiss general population, including 435 persons aged 19-84 years.
  • Multivariable linear regression models were run separately by sex, with age, education, and place of residence as confounders.
  • Outcomes were BMI, skeletal muscle mass index (SMI), FMI, and VAT, measured by bioimpedance analysis.

Physical activity was negatively associated with body fat measures in both sexes, especially in men.

  • The abstract states PA was negatively associated with FMI and VAT, 'especially in men'.
  • Models were adjusted for age, education, and place of residence.

Physical activity was associated with BMI in men but not in women.

  • This sex-specific association was found in the sex-stratified multivariable linear regression models.

Overall diet quality was associated with body composition measures in women but not in men.

  • Diet was assessed with a food frequency questionnaire.
  • Sex-stratified models showed associations between diet quality and body composition only in women.

Meat consumption was positively associated with SMI and FMI in women but not in men.

  • The association was seen for both skeletal muscle mass index and fat mass index in women.
  • No such association was found in men.

In men, fruit and wholegrain food consumption were negatively associated with FMI.

  • This association was reported for men specifically.
  • Food groups were derived from the food frequency questionnaire.

VAT was negatively associated with fruit intake in women, and with fruit and wholegrain intake in men.

  • Fruit was inversely associated with VAT in both sexes.
  • Wholegrain foods were inversely associated with VAT only in men.

The sex-specific patterns are consistent with evolutionary hypotheses on sex-specific energy allocation and may inform more precise diet recommendations.

  • The authors note sex differences in the metabolism of different foods and in the response to physical activity.
  • Findings suggest that diet components relate to specific body compartments differently in men and women.

What This Means

This study looked at how diet and physical activity relate to different parts of the body's makeup, such as fat, muscle, and fat around the organs, in 435 Swiss adults aged 19 to 84. Body composition was measured with a bioimpedance device, and diet was assessed with a food frequency questionnaire. Men and women were analyzed separately. Older age was most strongly linked to more body fat and more visceral (belly) fat in both sexes. Physical activity was linked to lower fat, especially in men. Overall diet quality was linked to body composition in women but not in men. Specific foods also differed: meat was linked to more muscle and more fat in women only, while fruit and wholegrain foods were linked to less fat in men. Fruit was linked to less visceral fat in both sexes, and wholegrains in men. This research suggests that diet and activity may relate to body composition differently in men and women, which could eventually help make dietary advice more tailored. Because the study is cross-sectional, it shows associations at one point in time and cannot show that diet or activity caused the differences in body composition.

Check Your Own Numbers

Upload your bloodwork. We'll cross-reference your results against this study and 4,700 others.

Upload Your Labs

Have a question about this study?

Citation

Hosseini-Akhavan N, Bektashi B, Jaeggi A, Bender N. (2026). Different body components associate differently with diet quality and physical activity in men and in women: a cross-sectional analysis.. PeerJ. https://doi.org/10.7717/peerj.21821