Cardiovascular

Foot Muscle Size and Balance in Stroke: Evidence of Structural-Functional Dissociation.

TL;DR

Although stroke patients exhibited mixed size changes in foot-ankle structures, the dissociation between structural changes and balance function suggests that dysfunction is primarily attributable to central nervous system damage rather than to peripheral structural alterations.

Key Findings

Stroke patients showed significantly reduced peroneus longus muscle size compared to healthy controls.

  • Effect size was large (d = 1.14, p < 0.001)
  • Study included 90 stroke patients (3-12 months post-stroke) and 95 healthy controls
  • Muscle size was quantified using ultrasound imaging measuring thickness and cross-sectional area (CSA)
  • Peroneus longus is classified as an extrinsic foot muscle in this study

Stroke patients showed significantly reduced tibialis anterior muscle size compared to healthy controls.

  • Effect size was moderate-to-large (d = 0.70, p < 0.001)
  • Tibialis anterior is classified as an extrinsic foot muscle in this study
  • Muscle size was quantified using ultrasound imaging

Stroke patients showed significantly reduced flexor hallucis brevis muscle thickness compared to healthy controls.

  • Effect size was moderate-to-large (d = 0.76, p < 0.001)
  • Flexor hallucis brevis is classified as an intrinsic foot muscle in this study
  • Muscle size was quantified using ultrasound imaging

Stroke patients showed significantly increased plantar fascia thickness in both the middle and posterior segments compared to healthy controls.

  • Middle segment effect size: d = 0.74, p < 0.001
  • Posterior segment effect size: d = 0.71, p < 0.001
  • This represents an increase in plantar fascia thickness, in contrast to the reductions seen in muscle measurements
  • Plantar fascia segments were measured using ultrasound imaging

In healthy controls, foot muscle parameters strongly correlated with balance metrics, with flexor hallucis brevis thickness showing significant negative correlation with mediolateral displacement under eyes-closed conditions.

  • Flexor hallucis brevis thickness correlation with mediolateral displacement (eyes-closed): r = -0.52, p < 0.001
  • Balance was measured using a force platform recording center-of-pressure (CoP) parameters during 30-second static standing
  • Both eyes-open and eyes-closed conditions were tested
  • Multiple foot muscle parameters showed strong correlations with balance metrics in healthy controls

No significant correlations between structural parameters and balance metrics were observed in stroke patients after false discovery rate correction, indicating a structural-functional dissociation.

  • This finding was described as 'structural-functional dissociation'
  • False discovery rate correction was applied to account for multiple comparisons
  • This contrasts with the significant structure-balance correlations found in healthy controls
  • Study design was cross-sectional with stroke patients assessed 3-12 months post-stroke

The authors concluded that balance dysfunction in stroke patients is primarily attributable to central nervous system damage rather than peripheral structural alterations.

  • This conclusion was based on the observed structural-functional dissociation in stroke patients
  • Stroke patients exhibited 'mixed size changes' in foot-ankle structures (some reduced, some increased)
  • The authors recommend rehabilitation should focus on neuromuscular control training rather than isolated muscle strengthening
  • This interpretation distinguishes central (CNS) from peripheral (structural) contributors to balance dysfunction

What This Means

This research suggests that while stroke survivors show measurable changes in the size of foot and ankle muscles and tissues — including shrinkage in key muscles like the peroneus longus and tibialis anterior, and thickening of the plantar fascia — these physical changes do not appear to be what drives their balance problems. The study compared 90 stroke patients (measured 3-12 months after their stroke) to 95 healthy individuals using ultrasound imaging to measure foot structures and a force platform to measure balance during standing. In healthy people, larger foot muscles were associated with better balance, but in stroke patients, no such relationship was found even after rigorous statistical correction. This disconnect between structure and function — which the researchers call 'structural-functional dissociation' — suggests that the balance difficulties stroke survivors experience are driven primarily by damage to the brain and nervous system, not by the physical deterioration of foot muscles themselves. Even when muscles change in size after a stroke, those changes don't explain why a person struggles to maintain their balance. This research suggests that rehabilitation programs for stroke survivors may be more effective if they prioritize retraining the nervous system's ability to control movement — known as neuromuscular control training — rather than focusing mainly on building muscle size or strength in the foot and ankle. The findings point to the brain, not the foot, as the primary target for improving balance after stroke.

Have a question about this study?

Citation

Zhang X, Wu Y, Liu G. (2026). Foot Muscle Size and Balance in Stroke: Evidence of Structural-Functional Dissociation.. Journal of foot and ankle research. https://doi.org/10.1002/jfa2.70206