Female growth charts and bone age readings best reflect longitudinal growth and maturation in individuals with 45,X/46,XY DSD and provide the most accurate prediction of near-final height.
Key Findings
Results
Near-final height was similar between the two genitalia-based groups in children with 45,X/46,XY mosaicism.
Mean near-final height (nFH) was 157.5 cm in Group 1 (external genitalia score [EGS] 0-4) and 160.3 cm in Group 2 (EGS 4.5-12).
The difference between groups was not statistically significant (n.s.).
Longitudinal growth data were available for 54 of the 95 total participants.
Groups were stratified by external genitalia score (EGS) to reflect degree of virilization.
Results
Growth in children with 45,X/46,XY mosaicism aligned more closely with female reference curves than male reference curves.
nFH was -0.7 SDS (Group 1) and -0.3 SDS (Group 2) when plotted on female growth charts.
nFH was -2.0 SDS (Group 1) and -1.6 SDS (Group 2) when plotted on male growth charts.
This pattern was consistent across both EGS groups.
The study used a multicenter retrospective registry-based cohort design across 26 participating centers.
Results
Bone age assessment yielded discordant results depending on whether male or female standards were applied.
Bone age was delayed when assessed using female standards.
Bone age appeared advanced when assessed using male standards.
Bone age was assessed centrally using the Greulich and Pyle method.
This discordance highlights the importance of reference standard selection in this population.
Results
Female-based predicted adult height (PAH) approximated near-final height more accurately than male-based PAH or target height (TH).
Female-based PAH slightly underestimated nFH.
Male-based PAH slightly overestimated nFH.
PAH approximated nFH more accurately than target height (TH) regardless of the reference used.
Both PAH and TH were evaluated as predictive metrics for final height outcomes.
Results
Near-final height was similar in individuals who did and did not receive growth hormone (GH) treatment, though interpretation was limited.
nFH did not differ significantly between GH-treated and untreated participants.
The authors noted interpretation was 'limited by small sample size and treatment bias.'
GH treatment outcomes were analyzed as a secondary aim of the study.
The finding does not allow firm conclusions about GH treatment efficacy in this population.
Methods
The study was a multicenter retrospective registry-based cohort study including 95 cases of 45,X/46,XY mosaicism from 26 centers.
Total cohort included 95 cases of 45,X/46,XY mosaicism.
Longitudinal growth data were available for 54 participants.
Twenty-six centers participated across multiple countries.
The study design was retrospective, and the authors called for 'larger prospective studies' to guide treatment decisions.
What This Means
This research examined how children with a specific chromosomal condition called 45,X/46,XY mosaicism — where some cells have one X chromosome and no Y, and others have both X and Y chromosomes — grow over time and how their bones mature. The study looked at data from 95 children across 26 medical centers worldwide, tracking height and bone development. A key question was which growth charts (male or female) best described these children's growth and could most accurately predict their adult height.
The researchers found that these children's growth patterns followed female reference charts much more closely than male ones. When their near-final heights were compared to female growth standards, they fell only slightly below average (-0.3 to -0.7 standard deviations), whereas compared to male standards, they fell well below average (-1.6 to -2.0 standard deviations). Similarly, bone maturation was better described using female standards. Using female-based calculations to predict adult height gave more accurate estimates than male-based calculations or estimates based on parental heights. Near-final heights were similar regardless of whether children had more male-typical or more female-typical genitalia at birth.
This research suggests that clinicians should use female growth charts and female bone age standards when monitoring growth and predicting adult height in children with 45,X/46,XY mosaicism, regardless of how their genitalia appear. The study also noted that growth hormone treatment outcomes could not be clearly assessed due to small numbers and differences between treated and untreated groups, highlighting the need for larger, prospective studies to better guide treatment decisions for this population.
Bosmans J, Herregods N, van Gremberghe I, van den Akker E, Atapattu N, Baronio F, et al.. (2026). Growth patterns and bone maturation in children with sex chromosomal (45,X/46,XY) differences of sex development.. European journal of endocrinology. https://doi.org/10.1093/ejendo/lvag092