Sleep

Impact of Noise from Heat Pumps on Sleep, Noise Annoyance, and Concentration in Healthy Adults in a Laboratory Setting.

TL;DR

Residential air-source heat-pump noise can impair both sleep parameters and daytime functioning, underscoring the need to consider its health impact in residential settings.

Key Findings

Air-source heat pump (AHP) noise with tilted windows led to significantly more noise-related arousals than with closed windows.

  • Noise-related arousals were 7.60 ± 5.90 (tilted windows) vs. 5.50 ± 3.60 (closed windows), p < 0.050
  • Study used polysomnography (PSG) across three nights: baseline (no noise), AHP noise simulating tilted windows, and AHP noise simulating closed windows
  • 40 subjects (21 female, 19 male) completed the study out of 42 initially enrolled; 2 discontinued for personal reasons
  • The tilted window condition simulated higher indoor AHP noise exposure than the closed window condition

Sleep disturbance reported via questionnaire was significantly greater in the tilted window condition compared to other conditions.

  • Subjective sleep disturbance was measured via questionnaires in addition to PSG
  • The tilted window condition produced the most pronounced self-reported sleep disturbance
  • This finding was based on within-subject comparisons across the three experimental nights

Total Sleep Time and Sleep Efficiency did not differ significantly across the three noise conditions.

  • Total Sleep Time across conditions: 418.20 min (363.10, 438.50), 408.20 min (352.90, 435.80), and 405.70 min (375.00, 430.20)
  • Sleep Efficiency across conditions: 87.10% (75.60, 91.30), 85.00% (73.50, 90.70), and 84.50% (78.10, 89.60)
  • No statistically significant differences were detected for these macro-level sleep architecture parameters
  • PSG was used to objectively measure these sleep parameters

Daytime exposure to AHP noise increased noise annoyance, concentration difficulties, and mood disturbances.

  • Subjects were exposed to AHP noise while reading texts, and responses were compared to a quiet baseline condition
  • A pronounced effect of the order of conditions on annoyance was found when noise followed the quiet condition: 2.58 ± 1.22 vs. 1.57 ± 0.60
  • The daytime study assessed concentration via questionnaires in addition to annoyance and mood
  • The order in which subjects experienced noise versus quiet conditions influenced their annoyance ratings

This study is the first to combine multi-night polysomnography and daytime testing to assess the effects of AHP noise on sleep and daytime functioning.

  • The study design included both a sleep component (3-night PSG) and a daytime reading/concentration task component
  • Outcomes measured included objective sleep architecture, noise-related arousals, subjective sleep disturbance, noise annoyance, concentration difficulties, and mood
  • The study was conducted in a laboratory setting, which the authors note limits generalizability of results
  • Residential air-source heat-pump installations are described as increasing, yet their impacts on sleep and noise annoyance were characterized as insufficiently understood

What This Means

This research suggests that noise from residential air-source heat pumps — a type of heating and cooling system that is becoming increasingly common — can affect both sleep quality and daytime wellbeing. In a controlled laboratory study, 40 healthy adults each slept three nights under different conditions: one quiet night and two nights with heat pump noise at levels representing either a tilted (slightly open) window or a fully closed window. The study found that while overall sleep duration and efficiency were not dramatically changed, the heat pump noise (especially with a tilted window) caused more brief awakenings during the night and greater feelings of sleep disturbance compared to the quiet condition. This suggests that even if people appear to sleep roughly the same total amount of time, the quality of their sleep may be quietly undermined by this type of noise. During the daytime portion of the study, participants were asked to read texts while exposed to heat pump noise, and they reported more annoyance, difficulty concentrating, and mood disturbances compared to when they read in a quiet environment. Notably, people who experienced the noisy condition after a quiet one reported higher annoyance levels, suggesting that the contrast between quiet and noise may amplify how bothersome the sound feels. This research suggests that heat pump noise, though often considered relatively low-level, may have real effects on residents' sleep and daily functioning, and these health impacts deserve consideration as heat pump use grows. The authors caution that because the study was done in a laboratory, the results may not perfectly reflect real-world experiences at home, and they call for larger, longer-term studies to better understand these effects.

Have a question about this study?

Citation

Benz S, Vassallo B, Braun M, Eulitz C, Penzel T, Glos M, et al.. (2026). Impact of Noise from Heat Pumps on Sleep, Noise Annoyance, and Concentration in Healthy Adults in a Laboratory Setting.. Noise &amp; health. https://doi.org/10.4103/nah.nah_147_24