Dietary Supplements

Intra-individual reliability of blood bicarbonate responses and gastrointestinal symptoms following sodium citrate supplementation.

TL;DR

Sodium citrate elicits a consistent group-level alkalosis yet individual timing metrics are unreliable, and a 2-3 hour ingestion window maximizes the probability of achieving ≥+5 mmol·L-1 above baseline.

Key Findings

Blood bicarbonate concentration rose significantly over time following sodium citrate ingestion, beginning at 30 minutes in both visits.

  • Twelve healthy males (21 ± 1 yr) ingested 0.5 g·kg-1 sodium citrate on two visits 3-7 days apart.
  • Capillary [HCO3-] was sampled at baseline and every 30 min up to 240 min.
  • The rise from baseline was statistically significant from 30 min onward in both visits (p < 0.001).
  • This finding indicates a consistent group-level alkalotic response to sodium citrate supplementation.

Reliability of baseline blood bicarbonate and area under the curve (AUC) was moderate, while peak bicarbonate reliability was poor.

  • Baseline [HCO3-] showed moderate reliability: ICC = 0.72 (95% CI: 0.25, 0.91); CV = 3.5%.
  • AUC showed moderate reliability: ICC = 0.56; CV = 3.5%.
  • Peak [HCO3-] showed poor reliability: ICC = 0.23 (95% CI: -0.29, 0.68); CV = 5.4%.
  • Concentration-based indices (baseline and AUC) were identified as more stable measures for monitoring individual responses.

All time-based metrics, including time to peak and time to exceed threshold elevations, demonstrated poor intra-individual reliability.

  • Time to peak (TTP) had an ICC = 0.07, typical error (TE) = 49.1 min, and CV = 32.5%.
  • Time to exceed +5 mmol·L-1 above baseline and time to exceed +6 mmol·L-1 above baseline also showed poor reliability.
  • The large TE of 49.1 min for TTP indicates that the timing of peak bicarbonate is highly variable within individuals across repeated trials.
  • These poor time-based reliability values limit the utility of individualized dosing strategies based on a single profiling session.

Monte Carlo simulation showed an ≥80% probability of exceeding +5 mmol·L-1 above baseline between 120 and 240 minutes post-ingestion.

  • The probability of exceeding +5 mmol·L-1 ranged from 83.9% to 85.8% across the 120-240 min window.
  • The probability of exceeding +6 mmol·L-1 peaked at 69.7% at 150 min.
  • These findings support a practical recommendation of a 2-3 hour ingestion window to maximize the probability of achieving a meaningful alkalotic threshold.
  • The simulation was used to estimate the probability of exceeding +5 and +6 mmol·L-1 thresholds at each individual time point.

Gastrointestinal symptoms following sodium citrate ingestion were common, unchanged across the two visits, and showed moderate reliability for overall burden.

  • GI symptoms were assessed using a 12-item questionnaire recorded concurrently with blood sampling at each visit.
  • Overall GI symptom burden was moderately reliable: ICC = 0.61; TE = 2.63; CV = 46.6%.
  • GI symptoms did not change significantly between the two visits, indicating a consistent symptom profile across repeated supplementation.
  • The high CV of 46.6% for GI burden indicates considerable relative variability despite moderate ICC.

Individual profiling was recommended for athletes requiring precise timing of peak bicarbonate, given the poor reliability of time-based metrics.

  • Despite a consistent group-level response, individual timing of peak [HCO3-] was highly variable (TTP CV = 32.5%).
  • The authors concluded that concentration-based indices are more stable for monitoring than time-based metrics.
  • A 2-3 hour ingestion window was recommended as the practical strategy to maximize the probability of exceeding +5 mmol·L-1.
  • Individual profiling was specifically recommended where precise timing relative to competition or exercise is critical.

Have a question about this study?

Citation

McManus C, Liew B, Waterworth S, Chung H. (2026). Intra-individual reliability of blood bicarbonate responses and gastrointestinal symptoms following sodium citrate supplementation.. Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition. https://doi.org/10.1080/15502783.2026.2629830