Mental Health

Mental Health, Gender Dysphoria, and Quality of Life in Trans Individuals Following Top Surgery: Protocol for a Prospective Cohort Study.

TL;DR

This paper describes the protocol for a prospective cohort study examining changes in mental health, gender dysphoria, risky behaviors, and quality of life in trans individuals (including nonbinary people) aged 16 and older following top surgery, using validated outcome measures at three time points.

Key Findings

Existing research on top surgery outcomes has significant methodological limitations that this study aims to address.

  • Most existing studies have been retrospective rather than prospective.
  • Prior studies have generally not used validated outcome measures.
  • Nonbinary individuals have largely been excluded from existing research.
  • The authors state these limitations restrict 'the robustness of the existing research.'

The study is designed as a longitudinal prospective cohort recruiting trans individuals aged 16 and older from a single surgeon's office in Perth, Western Australia.

  • Participants are recruited from a single surgeon's practice.
  • Eligibility includes trans and gender-diverse individuals aged 16 years and older undergoing top surgery.
  • The study explicitly includes nonbinary individuals, addressing a gap in prior research.
  • As of February 2026, 26 people had consented to participate.

Questionnaires are administered at three time points to capture pre- and post-surgical changes.

  • Time point 1: within 8 weeks prior to surgery.
  • Time point 2: 6-8 weeks post surgery.
  • Time point 3: 1 year post surgery.
  • Domains assessed include anxiety, depression, self-harm and suicide, gender euphoria and dysphoria, disordered eating, quality of life, substance use, social acceptance and discrimination, and surgical satisfaction.

The study employs multiple validated instruments alongside bespoke items developed through community consultation.

  • Validated instruments include the GENDER-Q (health professional subscale), Generalized Anxiety Disorder 7-item (GAD-7), Patient Health Questionnaire-9 (PHQ-9), Gender Euphoria Scale, an adapted Olson-Kennedy Chest Dysphoria Scale, International Physical Activity Questionnaire – Short Form, Eating Disorder Examination Questionnaire – Short, Assessment of Quality of Life 8 Dimensions, and Alcohol, Smoking, and Substance Involvement Screening Test – Short Form.
  • Bespoke items were developed through community consultation to capture experiences not covered by existing validated tools.
  • Surgical satisfaction is assessed using both patient- and surgeon-reported measures to enable between-group comparisons.

Quantitative and qualitative analytical approaches are both planned to analyze study data.

  • Quantitative data will be analyzed using linear regression models and repeated-measures ANOVA to compare outcomes across the three time points.
  • Qualitative data will undergo a general inductive approach to produce categories that contextualize and supplement quantitative findings.
  • Qualitative analysis is also designed to 'identify any novel or unexpected experiences.'

Data collection commenced in May 2025 and is expected to be completed by December 2027.

  • The study received funding in February 2024.
  • Data collection started in May 2025.
  • Expected completion is December 2027.
  • As of February 2026, 26 participants had consented.

The study aims to inform perioperative and postoperative care practices and policy related to gender-affirming surgeries in Australia.

  • Findings are intended to 'guide improvements in perioperative and postoperative care and support for patients.'
  • Results are expected to 'inform policy related to gender-affirming surgeries in Australia.'
  • The study is described as extending research on top surgery outcomes specifically within an Australian context.

What This Means

This paper describes the design and protocol for a research study that will follow transgender and gender-diverse people — including nonbinary individuals — before and after 'top surgery' (surgical procedures involving breast or chest tissue) to measure how their mental health, gender dysphoria, quality of life, and other wellbeing outcomes change over time. Participants aged 16 and older are recruited from a single surgeon's practice in Perth, Australia, and complete detailed questionnaires at three points: shortly before surgery, about six to eight weeks after surgery, and one year after surgery. The study uses established, validated measurement tools alongside questions developed with input from the trans community itself. This research suggests that a major gap exists in the current scientific literature on top surgery: most prior studies looked backward at past cases, did not use standardized or validated measures, and left out nonbinary people entirely. By following participants forward in time and using rigorous measurement tools, this study is designed to produce more reliable evidence about what people actually experience before and after top surgery across a broad range of outcomes, including anxiety, depression, self-harm, eating behaviors, substance use, physical activity, and social experiences like discrimination and acceptance. As of early 2026, the study had enrolled 26 participants and is expected to finish collecting data by the end of 2027. This research suggests that results could help healthcare providers better support trans patients during and after surgery and could also inform Australian policy decisions around access to gender-affirming surgical care.

Have a question about this study?

Citation

Bak J, Tan K, Ball J, Bonney S, Moore J, Hird K, et al.. (2026). Mental Health, Gender Dysphoria, and Quality of Life in Trans Individuals Following Top Surgery: Protocol for a Prospective Cohort Study.. JMIR research protocols. https://doi.org/10.2196/83928