Cardiovascular

Outcomes of Delayed Norwood Operation in High-Risk Patients-Time to Reconsider the Dogma of a Primary Norwood Operation?

TL;DR

The delayed Norwood approach preceded by bilateral pulmonary artery banding in high-risk patients achieved surgical outcomes comparable to those of lower-risk patients undergoing primary Norwood operation.

Key Findings

Bilateral pulmonary artery banding was performed very early in life as a bridge to the delayed Norwood operation in high-risk patients.

  • bPAB was performed at a median age of 2.5 days (IQR: 2-4)
  • 20 consecutive patients were included from a single centre between 2019 and 2024
  • All patients had hypoplastic left heart syndrome or variants with multiple risk factors
  • The study design was single-centre and retrospective

The study population carried a high burden of preoperative risk factors.

  • Prematurity was present in 35% of patients
  • Low birth weight (<2.5 kg) was present in 25% of patients
  • Non-cardiac comorbidities were present in 25% of patients
  • Genetic syndromes were present in 50% of patients
  • Preoperative cardiogenic shock was present in 35% of patients
  • Restrictive atrial septum was present in 25% of patients

The operative survival rate following the delayed Norwood operation was 75% in this high-risk cohort.

  • The median age at delayed Norwood operation was 36 days (IQR: 29-79)
  • Operative survival was 75% across all 20 patients
  • The authors noted these outcomes were comparable to those of lower-risk patients undergoing primary Norwood operation
  • The delayed Norwood was performed a median of approximately 33 days after initial bPAB

Patients who underwent the delayed Norwood within 4 weeks of bPAB did not require any pulmonary artery reinterventions.

  • PA reintervention rate was 0% in patients whose DN was performed within 4 weeks of bPAB
  • The authors suggest a DN procedure around 4-6 weeks following bPAB may reduce surgical or catheter-based reinterventions
  • PA reinterventions were a notable concern with longer intervals between bPAB and delayed Norwood

Postoperative hemodynamic recovery was demonstrated by rapid lactate clearance and significant reduction in vasoactive inotropic support.

  • Median lactate clearance time was 8 hours (IQR: 5-18) postoperatively
  • The median vasoactive inotropic score decreased by 47% within 48 hours postoperatively
  • These metrics were used as indicators of postoperative hemodynamic stability

Cerebral near-infrared spectroscopy values improved progressively in the early postoperative period in patients who did not require ECMO support.

  • In patients without postoperative ECMO, cerebral NIRS values improved from 53% at 0 hours to 58% at 12 hours and 63% at 36 hours postoperatively
  • Patients requiring postoperative ECMO did not demonstrate the same improvement pattern
  • NIRS was used as a surrogate measure of cerebral oxygenation and perfusion

The authors propose that a delayed Norwood performed approximately 4-6 weeks after bPAB may optimize outcomes in high-risk patients.

  • The proposed timing window of 4-6 weeks is intended to allow neonatal hemodynamic stabilization and organ maturation while minimizing risk of PA distortion requiring reintervention
  • The authors frame this as a reconsideration of the 'dogma of a primary Norwood operation'
  • The approach is positioned as an alternative for patients with preoperative cardiogenic shock, prematurity, low birth weight, non-cardiac comorbidities, genetic syndromes, and restrictive atrial septum

What This Means

This research suggests that for newborns with hypoplastic left heart syndrome (a serious congenital heart defect) who are considered very high-risk due to factors like prematurity, low birth weight, genetic conditions, or being in shock, a staged surgical approach may produce outcomes comparable to the standard immediate surgery. In this approach, a simpler initial procedure called bilateral pulmonary artery banding (bPAB) is performed within the first few days of life to stabilize blood flow, and the more complex Norwood operation is delayed for approximately 4-6 weeks until the baby is more stable and mature. In this study of 20 such high-risk patients, 75% survived the delayed Norwood operation, and postoperative recovery markers including lactate clearance and reduction in medication requirements were favorable. A notable finding was that babies who received the Norwood operation within 4 weeks of the initial banding procedure did not need any additional procedures on their pulmonary arteries afterward, suggesting that timing matters for minimizing complications. Brain oxygen monitoring (cerebral NIRS) also showed improvement in the hours after surgery in patients who did not need heart-lung bypass machine (ECMO) support for recovery, indicating adequate circulation to the brain. This research matters because high-risk newborns with this heart defect have historically faced very poor odds with the standard immediate Norwood surgery. By first stabilizing these fragile babies with a simpler procedure and waiting several weeks before the more complex surgery, this approach may offer these highest-risk infants a better chance at survival and recovery. The authors suggest their findings warrant reconsidering the standard practice of always performing the Norwood operation immediately after birth.

Have a question about this study?

Citation

Ozturk M, Selcuk A, Tongut A, Moynihan E, Desai M, Lopez Magallon A, et al.. (2026). Outcomes of Delayed Norwood Operation in High-Risk Patients-Time to Reconsider the Dogma of a Primary Norwood Operation?. Interdisciplinary cardiovascular and thoracic surgery. https://doi.org/10.1093/icvts/ivag218