Mental Health

Perspectives of female and under-represented physicians on well-being in medicine: a qualitative study from an academic medical centre in the USA.

TL;DR

Female and URM physicians face systemic challenges impacting their well-being and careers, with thematic analysis revealing four key themes: physician identity, well-being in the workplace, barriers to accessing well-being resources, and facilitators to well-being.

Key Findings

Thematic analysis of interviews with female and URM physicians revealed four key themes affecting their careers and well-being.

  • The four themes were: physician identity (URM, female, family), well-being in the workplace (emotional health, staffing burden, non-clinical responsibilities), barriers to accessing well-being resources (workplace environment, culture, overgeneralisation), and facilitators to well-being (physician camaraderie, leadership support).
  • Semi-structured interviews were conducted with 30 physicians at an urban academic health system.
  • Interviews were audio-recorded, transcribed and thematically analysed using a general inductive approach.
  • Interview guides were informed by prior literature and constructs.

The study sample consisted predominantly of female physicians with substantial racial and ethnic diversity.

  • 30 female or URM physicians were interviewed.
  • 27 (90%) of participants were female.
  • 14 (47%) identified as Black, Asian or multi-racial.
  • Participants self-reported demographic information including sex, race, ethnicity and tenure.
  • Participants were recruited via email from a large academic medical centre.

Physicians identified their intersecting identities as URM status, female gender, and family roles as influencing their experiences of well-being.

  • Physician identity emerged as one of four key themes in the thematic analysis.
  • Sub-themes within physician identity included URM identity, female identity, and family.
  • Physicians discussed how their identities influenced their experiences of well-being in academic medicine.

Emotional health challenges, staffing burdens, and non-clinical administrative responsibilities were identified as contributors to stress and reduced well-being in the workplace.

  • Well-being in the workplace was one of four key themes identified.
  • Sub-themes included emotional health, staffing burden, and non-clinical responsibilities.
  • Physicians highlighted these factors as contributing to stress in their academic medical careers.

Workplace culture, workplace environment, and overgeneralization of interventions were identified as barriers to accessing well-being resources.

  • Barriers to accessing well-being resources constituted one of the four key themes.
  • Sub-themes included workplace environment, culture, and overgeneralisation.
  • Broad-based interventions that do not account for the specific needs of female and URM physicians were identified as a barrier.
  • Workplace culture was described as impeding access to well-being resources.

Physician camaraderie and supportive leadership were identified as facilitators of well-being and access to well-being resources.

  • Facilitators to well-being constituted one of the four key themes.
  • Sub-themes included physician camaraderie and leadership support.
  • Supportive leadership and camaraderie were identified as facilitators of access to well-being resources.

The authors conclude that tailored interventions, supportive leadership structures, and collaborative working cultures are crucial for sustaining a diverse physician workforce.

  • Female and URM physicians face systemic challenges impacting their well-being and careers.
  • Findings underscore the need to address systemic changes and specifically design programmes focused on promoting well-being and inclusivity of female and URM physicians.
  • Academic physicians who are female and URM face inequities in the workplace and beyond.
  • The authors note disproportionate effects on these individuals and overall workforce capacity.

Have a question about this study?

Citation

Agarwal A, Gonzales R, Sharma M, Schroeder D, Asch D, Mitra N, et al.. (2026). Perspectives of female and under-represented physicians on well-being in medicine: a qualitative study from an academic medical centre in the USA.. BMJ open. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2024-095757