Mental Health

Pre- and post-COVID-19 pandemic changes in quality of life among medical trainees: impairment and recovery assessed using the WHOQOL questionnaire.

TL;DR

More favourable QoL trajectories were observed during the COVID-19 pandemic, with pre-pandemic scores consistently lower, marked declines followed by only partial recovery, while the pandemic period was characterized by higher and more stable trajectories, particularly with sustained improvements in the environmental domain and greater stability in psychological and social well-being.

Key Findings

Physical health domain scores among medical trainees declined sharply in the first six months of training and showed partial recovery by month 42.

  • Scores decreased from 49.0 (SD: 13.1) at baseline to 40.1 (SD: 11.0) at month 6
  • Recovery was observed to 47.6 (SD: 12.8) by month 42
  • Change was statistically significant (p < 0.001)
  • Study involved 420 postgraduate physicians from a Colombian university measured every six months over 42 months

Psychological health scores showed a two-phase decline, with an initial drop at month 6 and a further decrease at month 24, followed by partial recovery by month 42.

  • Scores declined from 64.8 (SD: 10.1) at baseline to 57.1 (SD: 11.6) at month 6
  • A further drop occurred at month 24 to 43.6 (SD: 11.3)
  • Recovery to 60.1 (SD: 12.4) was observed by month 42
  • Change was statistically significant (p < 0.001)
  • The nadir at month 24 corresponded to the pandemic period

Social relationships domain scores decreased from baseline and subsequently stabilized without full recovery.

  • Scores decreased from 68.2 (SD: 18.6) at baseline to 57.6 (SD: 19.6)
  • After the initial decline, scores stabilized rather than recovering
  • Change was statistically significant (p < 0.001)
  • During the pandemic period, greater stability in the social domain was observed compared to the pre-pandemic period

Environmental domain scores improved over the study period, with higher values observed during the pandemic.

  • Scores improved from 58.3 (SD: 12.9) at month 6 to 65.2 (SD: 14.3) at month 42
  • Higher environmental domain values were observed during the pandemic period
  • Change was statistically significant (p = 0.009)
  • Progressive improvement in the environmental domain was a distinguishing feature of the pandemic period

During the pre-pandemic period, QoL scores across all domains were consistently lower with marked initial declines and only partial subsequent recoveries.

  • Pre-pandemic scores showed initial declines and partial subsequent recoveries across all four domains
  • This pattern contrasted with the pandemic period which showed higher and more stable trajectories
  • The study period spanned 2016 to 2022, allowing direct comparison of pre-pandemic and pandemic epochs
  • Measurements were taken every six months over a 42-month period

The study sample consisted predominantly of young women in postgraduate medical training at a Colombian university.

  • Mean age was 27.9 years (SD: 3)
  • 63.3% of participants were women
  • 420 postgraduate physicians (residents and medical specialists in training) were enrolled
  • This was a prospective longitudinal study from 2016 to 2022

The COVID-19 pandemic period was associated with higher and more stable QoL trajectories compared to the pre-pandemic period across multiple domains.

  • During the pandemic, higher scores and more stable trajectories were observed across psychological, social, and environmental domains
  • Sustained improvements were noted in the environmental domain during the pandemic
  • Greater stability in psychological and social well-being was observed during the pandemic compared to pre-pandemic
  • This finding was described as counter-intuitive given the general expectation of pandemic-related QoL deterioration

What This Means

This research followed 420 medical residents and specialist trainees in Colombia over six years (2016–2022), measuring their quality of life every six months using a validated questionnaire (WHOQOL) that covers physical health, psychological health, social relationships, and environment. The study found that entering postgraduate medical training was associated with significant drops in quality of life, particularly in physical and psychological health, within the first six months. While some recovery occurred over time, quality of life never fully returned to baseline levels in most domains — suggesting that the demands of medical training have a lasting negative impact on trainees' well-being. Surprisingly, the COVID-19 pandemic period was not associated with worse quality of life compared to the pre-pandemic period. Instead, trainees during the pandemic reported higher and more stable scores, especially in environmental well-being, and showed greater psychological and social stability. This may reflect changes in training structure during the pandemic, such as reduced in-person obligations, remote learning, or shifts in workload distribution, though the study does not specify the exact causes. This research suggests that the structure and demands of medical training itself — independent of a global pandemic — may be a major driver of poor quality of life among trainees. The findings highlight an ongoing need to examine and potentially reform postgraduate medical training programs to better support trainee well-being, and raise questions about what protective factors during the pandemic might be applied to improve conditions in normal training environments.

Have a question about this study?

Citation

Tuta-Quintero E, Diaz-Quijano D, Bastidas A, Rios F, Duque C, Munar L, et al.. (2026). Pre- and post-COVID-19 pandemic changes in quality of life among medical trainees: impairment and recovery assessed using the WHOQOL questionnaire.. BMC medical education. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12909-026-08578-0