In this cluster randomized clinical trial, a cocreated preschool physical activity policy did not increase children's physical activity beyond usual practice after 6 months.
Key Findings
Results
The cocreated preschool PA policy did not change moderate to vigorous physical activity (MVPA) during preschool hours more than usual practice.
MVPA increased from 27.4 to 33.0 minutes per day in the intervention group and from 27.6 to 33.0 minutes per day in the control group.
Difference in change was 0.3 minutes per day (95% CI, -0.7 to 1.3; P = .57).
MVPA was measured with wearable accelerometers during preschool hours and was a prespecified primary outcome.
Results
The policy did not change total physical activity during preschool hours relative to usual practice.
Total PA increased from 177.7 to 185.3 minutes per day in the intervention group and from 176.5 to 184.5 minutes per day in the control group.
Difference in change was -0.3 minutes per day (95% CI, -3.3 to 2.7; P = .84).
Results
The policy did not change daily step counts during preschool hours relative to usual practice.
Steps increased from 5415 to 5953 per day in the intervention group and from 5549 to 6078 per day in the control group.
Difference in change was 8 steps per day (95% CI, -118 to 133; P = .90).
Results
Physical activity rose similarly in both groups over the 6-month period regardless of the intervention.
MVPA rose by about 5.6 minutes per day in the intervention group and about 5.4 in the control group.
Steps rose by roughly 500 to 540 per day in both groups.
Results
The trial was large, with all randomized preschools completing follow-up.
Of 156 randomly sampled preschools invited, 124 were randomized; all 124 completed follow-up.
3751 children (mean [SD] age 4.44 [0.86] years; 51.6% male) were included; 1960 attended intervention and 1791 attended control preschools.
Accelerometer data were available for 1530 (78.1%) intervention and 1430 (79.8%) control children at baseline, and 1435 (73.2%) and 1356 (75.7%) at follow-up.
Intention-to-treat analyses included 3417 children (1770 intervention, 1647 control).
Results
No participants withdrew because of adverse events.
Safety was reported alongside the primary outcomes in this pragmatic trial.
Conclusions
The authors conclude that adopting a PA policy does not readily translate into measurable behavior change in preschool children.
The findings highlight the complexity of translating policy adoption into measurable behavioral change and of detecting such change in preschool settings.
The trial was single-blind, parallel-group, and cluster randomized, conducted in public preschools in Stockholm, Sweden, with the 6-month follow-up in March to June 2021 (during the COVID-19 period).
What This Means
This study tested whether giving preschools a physical activity policy, developed together with the people who work in them, would get children moving more. Researchers in Stockholm randomly assigned 124 public preschools either to put the policy into practice for 6 months or to carry on as usual. Over 3,700 children aged 3 to 5 wore activity monitors during preschool hours before and after the 6 months.
Children in both groups became more active over time, but the increases were almost identical. Children in policy preschools and in usual-practice preschools gained about 5.5 minutes of moderate-to-vigorous activity per day, and their total activity and step counts rose by similar amounts. The differences between groups were tiny and not statistically meaningful. No children left the study because of harm from the intervention.
This research suggests that simply putting a physical activity policy in place at the preschool level may not be enough to measurably increase how much young children move during the day. The authors point out that turning a policy into real changes in behavior is complex, and that such changes can be hard to detect in preschool settings. Other approaches or stronger implementation support may be needed to boost children's activity.
Check Your Own Numbers
Upload your bloodwork. We'll cross-reference your results against this study and 4,700 others.