Dietary Supplements

Psychological manipulation mechanisms of false fitness and supplement information and public health risks: from information manipulation to behavioral decision-making.

TL;DR

Persuasive impact of false fitness and supplement information was driven largely by interface cues and social validation signals rather than credibility of evidentiary content, with heuristic trust linked to lower risk perception and stronger purchase intention through a statistically reliable indirect pathway.

Key Findings

Heuristic trust and perceived credibility were generally high among participants exposed to false fitness and supplement advertisements.

  • Heuristic trust mean was 4.50 (SD = 0.60)
  • Perceived credibility mean was 6.54 (SD = 0.44)
  • Study used a randomized online experiment with N = 630 participants
  • Participants viewed simulated social-media advertisements manipulating authority endorsement, scarcity framing, and conformity cues in a 2×2×2 design along with a truthful control condition

Higher heuristic trust and perceived credibility were closely linked to lower risk perception and stronger purchase intention.

  • Risk perception mean was low at 1.79 (SD = 0.39)
  • Purchase intention mean was 5.02 (SD = 0.68)
  • Risk perception exerted a substantial negative association with purchase intention
  • The indirect pathway from heuristic trust to intention through risk perception was statistically reliable (indirect effect = 0.279, 95% CI [0.230, 0.329])

Persuasive impact of false fitness and supplement claims was driven largely by interface cues and social validation signals rather than by the credibility of evidentiary content.

  • Manipulated cues included authority endorsement, scarcity framing, and conformity cues
  • Structural modeling confirmed these interface-level features shaped behavioral intention
  • Social validation signals played a larger role than evidence-based credibility in determining persuasive impact
  • This pattern held across all experimental conditions

Health literacy showed a consistent pattern in which higher literacy was associated with a stronger negative slope of risk perception on intention, but this interaction was not statistically significant.

  • Higher health literacy was associated with a stronger negative relationship between risk perception and purchase intention
  • The interaction term was not statistically significant in the moderation model
  • The pattern was described as 'consistent' despite not reaching statistical significance
  • Health literacy was examined as a moderator in the structural model

Repeated exposure to unregulated persuasive cue structures in online health-related advertising may gradually normalize low perceived risk and heighten purchase intention.

  • Authors argue that if persuasive cue structures remain unregulated, normalization of low perceived risk may occur over time
  • This normalization was described as posing 'longer-term challenges for consumer protection and public-health governance'
  • The study design used simulated social-media advertisements to model real-world exposure conditions
  • The findings point to implications for regulating interface-level features in health advertising

Have a question about this study?

Citation

Huang T, Leng X, Guo J, Guo Y, Zhao Y. (2026). Psychological manipulation mechanisms of false fitness and supplement information and public health risks: from information manipulation to behavioral decision-making.. Frontiers in public health. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpubh.2026.1718168