School nurse-involved sexual and reproductive health educational interventions can effectively enhance adolescents' SRH knowledge (SMD=1.36), but show no significant changes in attitudes or behaviours, with effective programs relying on active learning, consistent education, and interdisciplinary collaboration.
Key Findings
Results
School nurse-involved SRH interventions significantly improved adolescents' knowledge compared to control groups.
Standardized mean difference (SMD) = 1.36 for knowledge outcomes
95% confidence interval: (0.46, 2.26)
High heterogeneity was observed across studies (I2 = 93%)
19 total studies were included, with 12 quantitative studies contributing to the knowledge meta-analysis
Results
School nurse-involved SRH interventions showed no significant changes in adolescents' attitudes or behaviours.
Despite significant knowledge gains, attitude outcomes did not show statistically significant improvement
Behavioural outcomes also showed no significant changes
This gap between knowledge improvement and attitude/behaviour change was a key finding across the quantitative studies reviewed
Methods
The majority of included quantitative studies had a high risk of bias.
75% of quantitative studies were assessed as having a high risk of bias
Risk of bias was assessed using RoB 2.0, RoB 2 for Cluster Randomized Trials (CRT), and RoBANS 2
Qualitative studies were assessed using the JBI Critical Appraisal Checklist for Qualitative Research
19 studies were included in total: 12 quantitative and 7 qualitative
Results
Key facilitators of effective school nurse-involved SRH education included school nurses' expertise, trust, and active learning approaches.
These facilitators emerged from the qualitative synthesis component of the mixed-methods review
School nurses' established trust with students was identified as a distinct facilitator
Active learning strategies were highlighted as important components of effective delivery
These findings came from the 7 qualitative studies included in the review
Results
Key barriers to school nurse-involved SRH education included limited time, lack of materials, passive parents, and rigid policies.
Barriers were identified through qualitative synthesis using the JBI convergent segregated approach
Passive parental involvement was identified as a specific barrier distinct from active resistance
Rigid institutional or governmental policies were noted as structural barriers
Limited resources (time and materials) represented practical implementation challenges
Results
Integrated mixed-methods findings indicated that effective school nurse-involved SRH education relies on active learning, consistent education, and cross-disciplinary collaboration.
The review used the Joanna Briggs Institute (JBI) convergent segregated approach to integrate quantitative and qualitative findings
Consistency of educational delivery over time was highlighted as a key element
Collaboration across disciplines (not solely school nurses) was identified as necessary for effectiveness
The multi-database search was conducted between March and May 2024
What This Means
This research synthesized evidence from 19 studies (12 quantitative and 7 qualitative) conducted in high-income countries to understand how school nurse-led sexual and reproductive health (SRH) education affects teenagers. The analysis found that when school nurses deliver or are involved in SRH education programs, students' knowledge about sexual and reproductive health improves substantially. However, these programs did not appear to change students' attitudes toward SRH topics or their actual health-related behaviors in measurable ways. It is worth noting that three-quarters of the quantitative studies included had a high risk of bias, and the results showed very high variability between studies, which means the knowledge findings should be interpreted with some caution.
The qualitative portion of the review revealed that school nurses bring unique advantages to SRH education, including established trust with students and relevant health expertise. Programs that used interactive, active learning methods rather than passive instruction were seen as more effective. However, school nurses and programs face real-world obstacles including not having enough time, insufficient educational materials, parents who are not engaged, and school or government policies that restrict what can be taught.
This research suggests that school nurses can play a meaningful role in improving what adolescents know about sexual and reproductive health, but that translating knowledge into changed attitudes and behaviors likely requires more comprehensive approaches—including consistent, ongoing education and collaboration among teachers, health professionals, families, and policymakers. Addressing structural barriers like policy rigidity and resource limitations may be important for making these programs more effective in practice.
Choi Y, Seo H, Lee S, Park E, Yoon J, Noh S. (2025). School nurse-involved sexual and reproductive health education for adolescents' students in high-income countries: a mixed-methods systematic review.. Health education research. https://doi.org/10.1093/her/cyaf050