Cardiovascular

Sex Differences in Simultaneous Heart-Kidney Transplantation: A 25-Year United Network for Organ Sharing Analysis.

TL;DR

Women undergoing simultaneous heart-kidney transplantation demonstrated an early post-transplant mortality signal concentrated within the first 90 days, without excess long-term risk, underscoring the need for earlier referral and perioperative optimization of high-risk women to improve equity in SHKT outcomes.

Key Findings

Women represented only 19.7% of simultaneous heart-kidney transplantation (SHKT) recipients over the 25-year study period.

  • Total cohort included 3068 recipients identified from the United Network for Organ Sharing (UNOS) registry.
  • Study period spanned January 1, 1999, to September 30, 2024.
  • Only 604 of 3068 recipients were women (19.7%).
  • Rates of SHKT by sex were examined across allocation-policy eras.

Women undergoing SHKT were more likely to have nonischemic cardiomyopathy and higher pulmonary vascular resistance compared to men.

  • Women were more likely to have nonischemic cardiomyopathy as the underlying etiology.
  • Women had a higher pulmonary vascular resistance at the time of transplant.
  • Women were less likely to have durable left ventricular assist device (LVAD) support at the time of transplant.
  • These differences represent baseline clinical distinctions between male and female SHKT recipients.

Unadjusted post-transplant survival did not differ significantly between men and women at 1 or 5 years after SHKT.

  • Log-rank P = .236 for 1-year survival comparison by sex.
  • Log-rank P = .593 for 5-year survival comparison by sex.
  • No sex differences were observed at 5 years in the unadjusted analysis.

After multivariable adjustment, sex violated the proportional hazards assumption, necessitating a piecewise constant Cox model that revealed a numerically higher perioperative hazard for women.

  • In the full cohort, the perioperative adjusted hazard ratio (aHR) for women was 1.38 (P = .061), which did not reach statistical significance.
  • The postperioperative aHR for women in the full cohort was 1.19 (P = .473), also not significant.
  • Because sex violated proportional hazards, a piecewise constant Cox model was used rather than a standard multivariable Cox regression.

In a prespecified 90-day landmark analysis, women had a significantly higher risk of mortality in the first 90 days post-SHKT but not thereafter.

  • Days 0–90: aHR 1.58, 95% confidence interval 1.12–2.22, P = .009.
  • Days 91–365: aHR 0.91, P = .729, indicating no excess risk beyond 90 days.
  • This perioperative mortality disparity was concentrated within the first 90 days after transplantation.

The perioperative mortality disadvantage for women was most pronounced in the contemporary allocation era.

  • In the contemporary allocation era subgroup, women had an aHR of 1.78 (95% CI 1.19–2.65, P = .005) in the perioperative period.
  • This was a stronger effect than seen in the full cohort analysis (aHR 1.38, P = .061).
  • The contemporary era analysis suggests the disparity has not diminished under newer allocation policies.

No significant sex interactions were identified across 10 prespecified effect modifiers.

  • All interaction P-values were greater than .005 across the 10 prespecified subgroup analyses.
  • This indicates the early perioperative mortality signal in women was consistent and not driven by any particular subgroup.
  • No sex differences were observed at 5 years in any subgroup.

What This Means

This research analyzed 25 years of national transplant registry data to understand whether men and women have different outcomes after receiving a simultaneous heart and kidney transplant (SHKT). The study included 3,068 adults who received this complex dual-organ transplant between 1999 and 2024, of whom fewer than 1 in 5 (19.7%) were women. Women who received SHKT tended to have different underlying heart disease (more non-ischemic cardiomyopathy), higher pressures in their lung circulation, and were less likely to have been supported by a mechanical heart pump before transplant compared to men. While overall survival rates at 1 and 5 years looked similar between men and women on the surface, more detailed statistical analysis revealed that women faced a significantly higher risk of dying in the first 90 days after the transplant — about 58% higher risk than men during this early window. Importantly, this early disadvantage did not persist: after 90 days, women's survival outcomes were comparable to men's, and no differences were seen at 5 years. This early mortality gap was even more pronounced when looking only at patients transplanted under the most recent organ allocation policies, suggesting the problem has not improved in recent years. This research suggests that the critical period for women undergoing SHKT is the immediate post-transplant phase, and that the long-term outcomes for women who survive this early period are similar to men. The findings highlight a need to identify women who may benefit from SHKT earlier in their disease course and to focus on optimizing their care around the time of surgery, as a means of improving fairness in transplant outcomes between men and women.

Have a question about this study?

Citation

Ramu B, Shabbir A, Masotti M, Schultz J, Maharaj V, Alexy T, et al.. (2026). Sex Differences in Simultaneous Heart-Kidney Transplantation: A 25-Year United Network for Organ Sharing Analysis.. Journal of cardiac failure. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cardfail.2026.06.019