Exercise intolerance in HFpEF is associated with increased intermuscular fat and impaired whole body and quadriceps muscle oxidative capacity, but because intermuscular fat was not associated with oxidative capacity measures, the two appear to affect exercise tolerance via different physiological mechanisms.
Key Findings
Results
Lean thigh mass was similar between HFpEF patients and healthy older adults, but intermuscular fat percentage was significantly greater in HFpEF.
Thigh tissue composition was measured with T2-weighted MRI.
LTM did not differ between groups (P = 0.854).
IMF% was significantly greater in HFpEF (P ≤ 0.001).
Results
HFpEF patients had lower exercise tolerance and whole body aerobic capacity normalized to lean thigh mass than healthy older adults.
Peak watts and V̇o2peak were assessed with a graded exercise test on a cycle ergometer.
Peak watts and V̇o2peak normalized to LTM were lower in HFpEF (all P < 0.03).
Results
Quadriceps oxidative capacity was impaired in HFpEF, with a slower phosphocreatine recovery time constant.
In vivo quadriceps oxidative capacity was measured with 31P-MRS (τPCr).
τPCr was slower in HFpEF than in healthy older adults (P < 0.03).
Results
Intermuscular fat percentage was associated with peak watts normalized to lean thigh mass and with whole body V̇o2peak normalized to body mass.
IMF% vs peak watts/LTM: R2 = 0.148.
IMF% vs V̇o2peak/body mass: R2 = 0.347.
Results
Intermuscular fat percentage was not associated with V̇o2peak normalized to lean thigh mass or with quadriceps τPCr.
IMF% vs V̇o2peak/LTM: R2 < 0.001.
IMF% vs τPCr: R2 = 0.020.
The authors interpret this as steatosis and oxidative capacity affecting exercise tolerance through different mechanisms.
Results
V̇o2peak normalized to lean thigh mass and quadriceps τPCr were each associated with peak watts and with each other.
V̇o2peak/LTM vs peak watts: R2 = 0.509.
τPCr vs peak watts: R2 = 0.252.
V̇o2peak/LTM vs τPCr: R2 = 0.298.
Conclusions
The authors conclude that exercise intolerance in HFpEF is associated with increased muscle steatosis and impaired whole body and quadriceps oxidative capacity, which act via distinct mechanisms.
Steatosis (IMF%) related to exercise tolerance but not to oxidative capacity measures.
Oxidative capacity measures (V̇o2peak/LTM and τPCr) related to exercise tolerance and to each other.
What This Means
This study compared 38 older adults with heart failure with preserved ejection fraction (HFpEF) to 17 healthy older adults of similar age. Participants did a cycling exercise test, and MRI-based methods were used to measure fat within the thigh muscle and how well the thigh muscle regenerates energy after exercise, a marker of its ability to use oxygen.
The amount of thigh muscle was similar in both groups, but people with HFpEF had more fat within the muscle, lower exercise capacity relative to their muscle mass, and slower recovery of muscle energy stores, which suggests poorer muscle oxidative capacity. Both lower oxidative capacity and greater muscle fat were linked to poorer exercise performance. However, muscle fat was not related to the measures of oxidative capacity, which suggests the two problems may limit exercise through different pathways.
This research suggests that exercise limitation in HFpEF involves problems in the skeletal muscles themselves, not just the heart, and that more than one muscle problem may be involved. The study was a cross-sectional comparison, so it shows associations rather than cause and effect. The HFpEF group also had a higher body mass index than the healthy group.
Check Your Own Numbers
Upload your bloodwork. We'll cross-reference your results against this study and 4,700 others.