Mental Health

'Sometimes sheep need a vet': A qualitative study of Pentecostal clergy knowledge, attitudes, beliefs, and behaviours regarding mental health.

TL;DR

PAOC ministers hold nuanced, multifactorial views on mental health including both biomedical and spiritual attributions, typically offer spiritual care themselves while also making referrals to mental health professionals, but largely report a lack of formal mental health training and inconsistent support from the wider church.

Key Findings

Pentecostal clergy held a multifactorial understanding of mental illness that incorporated both biomedical and spiritual attributions.

  • 29 PAOC ministers participated in semi-structured qualitative interviews
  • Participants acknowledged biomedical causes of mental illness alongside beliefs in spiritual causes
  • Clergy also held beliefs in divine healing as a component of their understanding of mental distress
  • Data was analyzed using thematic analysis techniques

PAOC ministers typically offered spiritual care themselves to congregants experiencing mental distress.

  • Participants provided some level of spiritual care as a first response to mental distress
  • Clergy recommended church-based curricula as part of their pastoral care response
  • This spiritual care was offered alongside, not exclusively instead of, professional referrals

PAOC ministers frequently urged formal mental health service use and made referrals to mental health professionals.

  • Participants often directed congregants toward formal mental health services
  • The study title metaphor 'Sometimes sheep need a vet' reflects clergy recognition that professional help is sometimes necessary
  • Referral behavior was described as common practice among the sample

The majority of PAOC ministers reported a lack of formal mental health training.

  • The sample 'largely reported a lack of formal mental health training'
  • Participants also reported inconsistent support from the wider church institution regarding mental health
  • All 29 participants had at least 2 years of experience offering pastoral care, yet formal training gaps persisted

Clergy may require additional training and support to better address mental health issues in congregants.

  • The study recommends that PAOC ministers receive additional formal mental health training
  • Wider church support for clergy handling mental health issues was described as inconsistent
  • Clergy are often the first point of contact for religious Canadians when in mental distress and can impact help-seeking behaviours, underscoring the importance of adequate preparation

Clergy serve as a primary point of contact for mental health concerns among religious Canadians.

  • Clergy are described as 'often the first point of contact for religious Canadians when in mental distress'
  • Clergy can impact help-seeking behaviours among their congregants
  • The Pentecostal Assemblies of Canada (PAOC) is described as a 'diverse and growing Christian denomination'
  • Eligibility required at least 2 years of experience offering pastoral care

Have a question about this study?

Citation

Muthaih J, Caplin A, Jarvis G, Whitley R. (2026). 'Sometimes sheep need a vet': A qualitative study of Pentecostal clergy knowledge, attitudes, beliefs, and behaviours regarding mental health.. PloS one. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0342407