Mental Health

The association between social capital and mental health among older people living with HIV: a systematic review.

TL;DR

Research on social capital and mental health among older people living with HIV remains insufficient and is dominated by studies of social support, which is generally associated with lower depressive symptoms and better mental well-being, while broader social capital dimensions are largely unexamined.

Key Findings

Only 10 articles out of 9,060 identified met inclusion criteria for the review of social capital and mental health among adults aged ≥50 living with HIV.

  • Seven databases were searched up to November 28, 2025.
  • Eligible studies quantitatively assessed at least one dimension of social capital in relation to a mental health outcome.
  • Two reviewers independently screened studies and assessed risk of bias using the Newcastle-Ottawa Scale.

Research has overwhelmingly focused on social support, leaving broader dimensions of social capital largely unexamined.

  • Nine of 10 studies measured social support.
  • Trust and civic participation were only partially captured within a broader social capital instrument in two reports from the same cohort.
  • Reciprocity and bonding/bridging/linking capital were not measured.

Higher social support was generally associated with lower depressive symptoms and better mental well-being, but the strength and significance of associations varied.

  • This finding applied to studies measuring social support.
  • The authors conclude the available evidence suggests a beneficial association between social support and mental health.

Community/society-level social capital showed mixed associations with mental health.

  • Only two reports, both from the same cohort, assessed community/society-level social capital.
  • Associations reported were mixed.

Evidence for mental health outcomes other than depressive symptoms was sparse.

  • Depressive symptoms were the predominant outcome examined.
  • Other outcomes had limited representation among the 10 included studies.

Substantial heterogeneity in instruments and operational definitions limited comparability, so findings were synthesized narratively.

  • Instruments measuring both social capital and mental health differed substantially across studies.
  • Social capital dimensions were inconsistently operationalized.
  • Owing to heterogeneity, no meta-analysis was performed.

The authors recommend standardized, multidimensional social capital measures and longitudinal designs in future research.

  • Longitudinal designs are needed to clarify directionality of associations.
  • The review was registered in PROSPERO (CRD42024537839).

What This Means

This systematic review looked for studies on whether social capital—such as social support, trust, and community participation—is linked to mental health in people aged 50 and older who live with HIV. Out of more than 9,000 articles screened, only 10 met the criteria, showing that this topic has received little research attention. Nearly all of the studies measured only social support. In these, having more support was generally linked to fewer depressive symptoms and better mental well-being, although how strong the link was differed between studies. The few studies that looked at broader community-level social capital found mixed results. Little evidence existed on mental health outcomes other than depression, and studies used very different measurement tools, making them hard to compare. This research suggests that social support may be beneficial for the mental health of older people living with HIV, but that the wider picture of social capital is still largely unknown. Because most studies were not designed to follow people over time, it is unclear whether support improves mental health or whether better mental health leads to more support. The authors call for more consistent measurement and long-term studies.

Have a question about this study?

Citation

Xia H, Cao X, He Y, Yang L, Yu Q. (2026). The association between social capital and mental health among older people living with HIV: a systematic review.. Frontiers in public health. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpubh.2026.1827140