Methods
A total of 57 articles were included in the scoping review after screening eight academic databases and grey literature.
- Databases were searched in May 2024 and again in June 2025.
- The review followed Arksey and O'Malley's (2005) five-stage iterative process and PRISMA-ScR guidelines.
- Articles published in all languages were considered.
- Grey literature was included alongside academic databases.
Results
Incarcerated trans, gender diverse, and non-binary people consistently face restricted access to gender-affirming healthcare.
- Restricted access to gender-affirming healthcare was identified as one of four major thematic categories.
- This finding was described as 'consistent evidence' across the international literature reviewed.
- The review categorized this under the theme of 'general and gender-affirming healthcare.'
Results
Incarcerated trans, gender diverse, and non-binary people experience systemic mental health challenges.
- Mental health and wellbeing was identified as one of the four major thematic categories in the review.
- The evidence on mental health challenges was described as 'consistent' across the included studies.
- Mental health challenges were framed as 'systemic' rather than individual in nature.
Results
Incarcerated trans, gender diverse, and non-binary people are exposed to high levels of violence.
- Violence was identified as a distinct thematic category among the four major themes.
- Exposure to violence was described as part of 'consistent evidence' across the international literature.
- Violence was treated as a separate thematic domain from mental health and healthcare access.
Results
Incarcerated trans, gender diverse, and non-binary people face sexual health risks and HIV care gaps.
- Sexual health and infectious disease was identified as one of the four major thematic categories.
- HIV care gaps were specifically highlighted as part of the consistent evidence.
- Sexual health risks were documented alongside broader infectious disease concerns.
Results
Trans, gender diverse, and non-binary people in prison demonstrate creativity and resilience in response to gender-affirming attire and grooming restrictions.
- Gender embodiment was identified as one of the four major thematic categories.
- Restrictions on gender-affirming attire and grooming were documented across the included studies.
- Despite these restrictions, creativity and resilience were identified as consistent responses among this population.
Results
The review identified significant geographic, thematic, methodological, and subpopulation knowledge gaps in the existing literature.
- Knowledge gaps were identified across four dimensions: geographic, thematic, methodological, and subpopulation.
- The review covered international literature, suggesting the gaps are global in nature.
- These gaps were noted despite the inclusion of 57 articles from multiple countries.
Conclusions
The review concludes that policies and interventions must be evidence-based, integrated, culturally responsive, sustainably resourced, and involve community experts and incarcerated people in their design and evaluation.
- Findings highlight 'the need for clear and consistently implemented prison policies and prison diversion strategies.'
- Policies must be developed 'in the face of populist discourse.'
- Community experts and incarcerated people are specifically identified as necessary participants in policy design and evaluation.