Mental Health

Transitions Between Forms of Employment Quality and Associations With Self-Rated Health and Mental Health in the United States, 2008-2022.

TL;DR

Respondents transitioning to or from low-EQ arrangements (e.g., precarious employment or unemployment) reported poor/fair self-rated health and mental health more frequently relative to high-EQ types, and some respondents cycled between precarious employment and unemployment, potentially compounding the effects of employment instability on health.

Key Findings

Five unique employment quality types were identified for men and four for women using latent transition analysis of U.S. Medical Expenditure Panel Survey data.

  • Male EQ types: 1. Salaried-Intensive; 2. Standard Employment Relationship (SER)-like; 3. Standard but Economically Vulnerable; 4. Precarious; and 5. Unemployed.
  • Female EQ types: 1. SER-like, Union; 2. SER-like, non-Union; 3. Precarious; and 4. Unemployed.
  • Data spanned 2008 to 2022 with n = 71,957 respondents (weighted n = 126,312,273).
  • The study used U.S. Medical Expenditure Panel Survey (MEPS) data.

Respondents transitioning to or from low employment quality arrangements reported poor or fair self-rated health more frequently than those in high-EQ types.

  • Low-EQ arrangements included precarious employment and unemployment.
  • High-EQ types included SER-like employment arrangements.
  • Associations of poor/fair self-rated health (SRH) with each EQ type were measured using generalized estimating equations.
  • The probability of reporting poor/fair SRH within each EQ transition was measured descriptively.

Respondents transitioning to or from low employment quality arrangements reported poor or fair self-rated mental health more frequently than those in high-EQ types.

  • Self-rated mental health (SRMH) outcomes were measured alongside self-rated health (SRH).
  • Low-EQ transitions (e.g., to or from precarious employment or unemployment) were associated with worse SRMH.
  • Associations were measured using generalized estimating equations.
  • Unemployed individuals were included in the EQ typology, unlike many prior studies.

Some respondents cycled between precarious employment and unemployment, potentially compounding the effects of employment instability on health.

  • The probability of transitioning between each EQ type was measured using latent transition analysis (LTA).
  • Cycling between precarious employment and unemployment was identified as a distinct pattern in the LTA results.
  • This cycling pattern was identified for both men and women, as both had a Precarious and an Unemployed EQ type.
  • The authors suggest this cycling may compound negative health effects of employment instability.

Unemployed individuals are frequently omitted from employment quality studies, representing a gap this study addressed by including unemployment as a distinct EQ state.

  • Unemployment was included as a separate EQ type for both men (type 5) and women (type 4).
  • The study notes that few prior studies have explored how transitions between types of EQ impact health in the U.S.
  • Including unemployment allowed the authors to capture cycling between precarious employment and unemployment.

Improving employment conditions, particularly for those caught in cycles of precarious employment and unemployment, was identified as a potential avenue for improving population health in the U.S.

  • This conclusion was drawn from the finding that low-EQ transitions were associated with worse self-rated health and mental health outcomes.
  • The study covered a 14-year period from 2008 to 2022, encompassing multiple economic cycles.
  • The weighted sample represented approximately 126,312,273 individuals in the U.S.

Have a question about this study?

Citation

Lundstrom E, Peckham T, Oddo V. (2026). Transitions Between Forms of Employment Quality and Associations With Self-Rated Health and Mental Health in the United States, 2008-2022.. American journal of industrial medicine. https://doi.org/10.1002/ajim.70057