Sound perception is shaped by contextual and semantic factors and cannot be fully captured by conventional acoustic metrics alone, as sites with comparable A-weighted sound pressure levels elicited different perceptual evaluations depending on the dominant noise source and its perceived meaning.
Key Findings
Results
Participants showed a consistent preference for green areas in the university district soundscape.
Five soundwalks were conducted in the university district of Milano-Bicocca in Milan.
Green areas were both preferred in subjective emotional response surveys and statistically clustered based on psychoacoustic indices.
The clustering aligned subjective responses with the psychoacoustic structure of the environment.
Squares and the two sites most exposed to traffic also formed distinct clusters.
Results
Sites with comparable A-weighted sound pressure levels (dBA) elicited different perceptual evaluations depending on sound source characteristics.
Environments featuring water sounds were systematically perceived as less noisy despite similar dBA levels to other sites.
Sites with the highest dBA levels were perceived either as chaotic or monotonous depending on the listener's subjective interpretation.
The perceived meaning of the dominant noise source influenced perceptual evaluation independently of the measured sound level.
This finding reinforces that conventional acoustic metrics alone are insufficient to fully capture sound perception.
Results
Psychoacoustic parameters derived from binaural recordings were statistically aligned with subjective emotional responses from participants.
Binaural recordings were used to determine psychoacoustic parameters at each soundwalk site.
Statistical clustering of sites based on psychoacoustic indices corresponded to groupings emerging from subjective survey responses.
The study compared subjective emotional responses with objectively measured psychoacoustic parameters across all five soundwalk sites.
Methods
Focus group discussions revealed participants' in-depth perceptions, everyday life accounts, geographical backgrounds, and habitual and preferred soundscapes.
A focus group discussion was conducted at the end of each of the five soundwalks.
Discussions explored participants' accounts of everyday life in the neighbourhood.
Participants' geographical backgrounds and habitual soundscapes were collected as contextual factors.
Preferred soundscapes were also documented through focus group methodology.
Conclusions
Sound perception in urban environments is shaped by contextual and semantic factors beyond what conventional acoustic metrics can capture.
The study used a multidimensional approach combining soundwalks, surveys, binaural recordings, psychoacoustic analysis, and focus groups.
The same dBA level produced systematically different perceptual outcomes depending on the semantic content of the soundscape.
Water sounds reduced perceived noisiness relative to measured levels, while traffic noise produced either chaotic or monotonous perceptions.
The results reinforce 'the hypothesis that sound perception is shaped by contextual and semantic factors, and cannot be fully captured by conventional acoustic metrics alone.'
Grecchi I, Guagliumi G, Azzimonti O, Costarelli I, Sibilia A, Brambilla G, et al.. (2026). Walk and listen: A multidimensional study on the soundscape of a University District.. PloS one. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0343065